Statement On Lennox By Sarah Fisher

Statement On Lennox By Sarah Fisher

It has been brought to my attention that a small clip of my assessment of Lennox has been put on the internet.  This clip has been taken completely out of context and whilst I have remained relatively quiet on this case since I spoke in court, I feel that I am now forced to make a statement to clarify what actually happened during the time I was with Lennox.

Wrongly or rightly many documents and details about this case have been passed onto different parties. I do not feel it is appropriate for me at this moment to discuss in detail everything that has been said to me, nor to put forward my own ideas regarding all the statements made, as everyone is entitled to their own opinion and beliefs.  What I am qualified to do however is to discuss behaviour. My assessments, statements and videos of those assessments have been accepted in other court cases at Magistrates, County and Crown Courts here in the UK so the field of assessment in cases such as this is not unknown to me.

I do not care if I am to be criticized by members of the public or even other professional bodies as I have a wealth of experience handling and working with many breeds of dogs, large and small and I also work with horses with behavioural issues so do not need to defend the claims that I have little or no experience of working with powerful animals such as Pit Bull Types. I would however like to clarify that a Pit Bull Type is often a mix of dogs.  Nothing extraordinary happens to the psyche of a dog when it conforms to certain measurements.

I do care however that Lennox is being portrayed in a poor light through this video clip as my experience of handling Lennox was thoroughly enjoyable and I now feel the need to explain in greater detail the truth, as I see it, about my assessment.  I know that Victoria Stilwell has been what I would consider to be a sane voice amidst the madness that surrounds this case and she has seen full video footage of the assessments carried out by myself and David Ryan plus other documentation.

When the door to the van was first opened Lennox barked.  He barked at me three times when I approached.  As I said in my report this is not uncommon behaviour in any dog that is in a confined situation in a crate, kennel or in a car.  He was also shaking like a leaf but this does not come over in the video that my assistant took of this assessment.  He was clearly frightened as he could not have known what was going to happen to him and again this is not an uncommon behaviour in the dogs that come to me for help. No one has ever disputed that Lennox can be anxious around some strangers but I believe the key word some has sadly been overlooked.

I asked for someone that Lennox knew to take him out of the crate to keep his stress levels low. Entry and exit points can be a source of conflict for any dog. I was told I had to handle Lennox on my own for the entire assessment and that he had bitten the last person that came to see him.  This is the clip that has been released.  Had I had any concerns for my safety or those around me given that I was to be fully and wholly responsible for a dog that I do not know and that I had been told has bitten, I would not have continued with the assessment if I believed that dog to be a danger either to myself or those who were standing in the car park. Lennox gave me a lot of information about his temperament whilst in the crate.  In court however, and therefore under oath, Ms Lightfoot the Dog Warden stated that in fact Lennox had not bitten anyone so I have to assume on the evidence placed before the court that the statement made to me at the start of my assessment was untrue.  Given the publicity surrounding this case I am also confident that had Lennox actually bitten anyone whilst in the care of his family as has been suggested someone would have come forward by now.

I spent approx 15 minutes with Lennox prior to being taken from the crate, working with a clicker and some treats to see if, even in the environment that was causing him some anxiety, he could still learn and take direction from a stranger. He could. His eyes were soft and he was friendly. At this point I would also like to clarify the meaning of the word friendly.  It does not mean confident.  Was Lennox anxious? Yes.  Hostile?  No.

I believe that Lennox would have been totally at ease had I indeed taken him out myself but I also believe I have a duty of care to reduce stress where possible when handling any animal in a situation that is causing them distress.  No doubt this statement will also be taken out of context by those who wish to discredit me and to discredit my belief that Lennox is not a danger to the public based on my experience with him and also based on the video assessment carried out by David Ryan which I have also seen.

I use food in an assessment to monitor the dogs stress levels and emotions at all times. It is not a bribe. A habitually aggressive dog will generally seek out conflict in my experience but even these dogs can often be rehabilitated. No amount of food can disguise this behaviour and giving food to a dog with aggression issues can be extremely dangerous. The dog may be lured to a person by the promise of food but once it has taken the food it may panic as the offering of the food has now brought that dog into close proximity with the threat i.e. a stranger. I have worked with dogs with aggression issues and whilst some may well take the food, the person delivering the food may not be able to move once the food has gone as the movement of the person, even the smallest movement of their arm, may trigger the dog to lunge and bite. I would not hand feed a dog that I deem to be aggressive. The delivery of the treat must come from the person that the dog knows and trusts – not the stranger. The dog can learn to approach a threat and then turn back to the person that the dog trusts for the reward if the approach to the person is appropriate.  I use food throughout an assessment to monitor what is happening with the dog on an emotional and physical level not to make him my best friend.

Lennox was so gentle with the taking of the food both in the crate and also later in the car park.  He was also appropriate in his behaviour with the games we played. He was also gentle when he jumped up at me to see if he was allowed the food that I was withholding in my hand. When he realised it wasn’t forthcoming he politely backed off. This would suggest to me that he has been around a family. Not chained up in a yard as has also been claimed by people who do not know the family or the dog.

Lennox showed excellent impulse control at all times and at no point did he grab me or my own clothing which many dogs do when getting excited by a game.  I have worked with some truly challenging dogs and some will become increasingly aroused by lead ragging or games with toys and start seriously mouthing or biting the handlers arms or clothing. This can quickly flip over to more overt aggression and these dogs can be dangerous particularly if they are being handled by just one person.  It is imperative that dogs with this behaviour are taught a more appropriate way of interacting with people and responding to the leash and also greater self control. There are many ways to help dogs that have been encouraged, through mishandling and misunderstanding, to behave in such a manner.  Kicking and beating them is certainly not the answer.

Lennox does rag on the lead but it is very self controlled. He did not exhibit any of the behaviours that I have mentioned above. Regardless of what some uneducated people may wish to think, it is possible to glean a lot of information about a dog through games and food as many behaviour counsellors and trainers will confirm.

I wrote a fifteen page report on my experience with Lennox and my thoughts about the David Ryan assessment. In this report I state that I have concerns about the appearance of Lennox’s neck. In the video I explain this too.  His ears are unlevel and there was a change in the lay of his coat over the Atlas in line with the nuchal ligament that is present between T1 and C2 vertebrae.  Coat changes often occur in dogs, cats and horses that have suffered injury or those that are unwell. I have studied this over seventeen years of handling many animals. In all cases where I referred an animal back to a vet, whether it was in the care of a shelter, owned by my private clients or students that I teach changes to the soft tissue or skeleton were noted on further detailed investigation.  When I see this around the neck in a dog I know that it is likely to give the dog cause for concern when someone unknown to that dog attempts to handle the collar or put on or take off a lead.  Coat changes may well be present where deep bruising has also occurred. Pain and pain memory is a key factor in many behavioural problems.

Lennox was quite rightly put on Amitriptyline. I do not believe that the Council have failed in their duty to care for Lennox when it comes to the stress that he has been under and I understand that this drug is used to treat anxiety and depression.  It was with interest, though, that I discovered that this drug is also used to treat chronic pain in dogs. Again this was mentioned in my written report.  This may explain in part why my experience with Lennox seems to fly in the face of other evidence presented before the courts. He was not on Amitriptyline when he was assessed by David Ryan.

I would absolutely move on to touch an animal all over its body in any assessment that I do.  I may or may not choose to muzzle a dog that is unknown to me to do this if I have concerns about the body language that I have seen prior to this part of my assessment.  I elected not to stroke Lennox all over because of my concerns about his neck, the newly forming scabs that were present on his flanks and the blood that was present around the nail beds around his right hind foot. This decision was made based on the physical evidence before me not because I felt I would be in danger.  I talked about this in court which was open to the public and at the end of my assessment which is also on film I explained this to a representative from the BCC Dog Warden team and asked if there was anything else that she would like me to do with Lennox.  She said no.

I cannot comment on what happened when Lennox was seized or measured by Peter Tallack because I wasn’t there. I can explain behaviour though and any frightened animal can be intimidating. I have recently been in Romania working with traumatised horses and two stallions had not been mucked out for months as the staff (men) were too scared to go in with them. They called them ‘pitbulls’ such is the misguided impression of this type of dog.  Hay had been simply thrown over the stable doors and their water buckets were hanging crushed against the stable wall.  I went in with them, not because I have any desire to be a hero, but because I can read an animal well and within minutes they were quiet, standing at the end of their stables albeit it pressed up against the walls. I was calm with them and we took out all the filthy bedding and fetched new water buckets for them too. They didn’t attack anyone. They were simply terrified and they were not provoked. I spent time with one of them on my own, hand feeding him and was finally able to touch his face. This process probably took less than half an hour. I was totally absorbed in what I was doing and when I turned to walk out I realised that one of the Romanian men had been watching me. He raised his eyebrows, gave me the thumbs up and walked away. Other people could then go in with this magnificent horse too and hand feed him the fresh sweet grass that we had picked from the surrounding fields so it isn’t simply that I am quiet in my handling of animals nor possess some extraordinary skill that can make even the most savage lion behave like a lamb when in my company.

I can perhaps, help an animal that is struggling, gain trust in human beings as many people can.  I can perhaps work with a difficult animal and make it look as though that animal is calm but all the time I am reading that animal. Every second of the way. I am looking at the eyes if it is safe to do so, I am watching the respiration, I am studying the movement, the set of the ears and the tail and so on and my opinions about an animal are based on many years of working in this way.  One case that will always stand out in my mind was a large member of the Bull Breed family.  I believe she was two years old.  I won’t go into the details here but I will say that when I worked with her she appeared to be very good to the member of kennel staff that was watching.  At the end of my assessment the member of staff asked me what I thought.  I sadly had to say that I thought the dog should be put to sleep. The member of staff was horrified and I remember her saying ‘but she’s been so good with you’.  But I had noticed some worrying signs.  The shelter ignored my advice and rehomed the dog who savaged the new owner so badly the owner ended up in the ICU. Of course the dog was immediately destroyed.

I knew what I was walking into when I agreed to go and assess Lennox for the family.  To have to defend Lennox outside of the court has, however, come as a surprise.  I have made this statement to shed a little more light on what is a distressing case for all those involved,  knowing full well that I will no doubt be subject to further scrutiny and criticism. So be it. I am not afraid. If nothing else this case has highlighted some important issues about the fears and prejudice concerning dogs, their breed types and their behaviour. Certainly it highlights the sad truth as Xenephon said so wisely in 400 BC. Where knowledge ends, violence begins.

The Save Lennox Campaign © 2011 Sarah Fisher


24 comments on “Statement On Lennox By Sarah Fisher

  1. A lovely story now RELEASE LENNOX,Northern Ireland had enough Bullshxt with Bruce the Staffy.Please beleive there will be many petitions from all over the world discouraging any form of spending in that Terrorist Haven.

  2. I have forwarded this to your full list of contacts on this website including the First Secretary of NI, as well as my own letter in support of freeing Lennox and changing the legislation. I have posted it on Twitter and FB and will send it anywhere else I think it or any other information might have a positive impact, ie, BBC NI, Belfast City Council however are censoring any mention of talk about Lennox and wrapping it up in red tape.

    • They do need to be made to free Lennox, who never did anything wrong. The fact that BCC is censoring talk about Lennox is because I believe they know that the world is really pissed off at what they have done and are continuing to do.

  3. Thank god America doesn’t do this…I’ll truly hurt someone if they come on my property trying to take my dog…actually I would make my pitbull attack that person bc if ur gonna take him to put him down, might as well go down with a fight! These dogs are family to us, imagine someone coming in your yard trying to take your kids or mother or husband! Nooooo wayyyyy! It ain’t right! The breed is not bad…people make a bad breed! Just like guns….guns don’t kill ppl but ppl with guns kills ppl! I say mind ya business & help animals that need it but not helping them by taking them away from their home!

    • actually …in the uk they DO come in your property and take kids .I know Ive had a hell of a row with the local council where I live And just yesterday I had a serious run in with the very same court as in the case of Lennox for example the judiciary (Stephens) and the Belfast city council legal department (walsh and quigley) told the press that they had “injuncted” ME… HOW??????? I dont live in their area and no particulars of claim had been served on me so it seems that quigley and stephens cooked up some piece of paper after the courts closed ,and put my name on it all very illegal and worse Stephens is a high court judge.
      Makes you wonder what else they could all be up to that we havent yet found out about…….

    • Nunya, Yes some counties and towns in America do have pitbull bans and other bully breed bans. But we must all fight to get these laws off the books. It is sad when a breed is condemed without any reason.

  4. Nunya, you’re wrong in saying America doesn’t do this; some cities/counties do have Pit Bull breed bans. If you are found in possession of a pit bull, not only do you face a fine, but the dog can be removed and destroyed. I believe Miami-Dade county has a Pit Bull breed ban and while they give you the chance to relocate the dog out of the county, some people don’t have the resources to relocate the dog and simply turn it over to be destroyed. I also know that in some Michigan counties, any dog turned in to the SPCA that is a pit bull breed (or mix) will be automatically destroyed. Hopefully the plight of Lennox will put a spotlight on these stupid and barbaric practices and each and every dog can be individually assessed based on it’s own temperament.

  5. Please let Lennox go home – if my dogs were put in this situation they would not behave this well! They just don’t happen to look like Lennox so they can get away with it !!!! IDIOTS – CRUEL IDIOTS

  6. yes because it is all about YOU isn’t it? You kill a dog, have no regard for the family, and NOW you have the NERVE to defend yourself?? GO TO HELL YOU SELFISH MURDERER

  7. and yet now, they have already killed him! Everything i read and see about Lennox and his situation, tells me that a crime has been commited, against a loving dog that never hurt a soul. RIP Lennox xxx

  8. If Lennoxs behavior was so good during the assessment why was he put down , you have explained alot but not why it is said Lennox was one of the most dangerous dogs that one of the handlers had met , why is there conflicting evidence , would you stand up and give evidence against the abuse Lennox had suffered when he first got took .

  9. Thank you Sarah for all that you did for Lennox and all you continue to do for animals and people lucky enough to know you. I’m sure Lennox found great comfort in spending some time with you and appreciated your understanding. Love x

  10. Sarah, it’s been a long time. I retired from dogs a long time ago but all I can say is that this is an amazingly well written and beautiful description of a behavioural assessment of a dog that has been seized under Breed Specific Legislation. I too did many of these assessments and also used food. I remember turning up for assessments surrounded by people wearing bite suits and holding catch poles. Thank you for offering such an insightful and intelligent overview of a temperament assessment of this type. It’s not an easy task. Like you, I had to assess dogs that sadly were very dangerous – but the whole point of being an expert is not to provide a defense under any circumstances. Experts to the court are there to share their expertise and provide a truthful assessment – and it seems that is exactly what you have done. Warm regards, Colette Kase

  11. Thank you so much for sharing this with us, Sarah. I found your report moving and very informative. I hope the world can learn something from this horrible, messed-up, tragic situation that has unfolded nastily for the world to see. Time will tell.

  12. he should have never been taken from his family who loved him an to not let them visit is so cruel should have let him come to usa so he could have lived his life with love not in a cell with his own feces

  13. Dear Ms Fisher, all I can say about this account is hank you for doing our best for Lennox what a disgrace they didn’t listen to sound advice from a very experienced and educated person. I agree with everything you have said here.

  14. How sad that this has now turned into an obituary, purely because BCC were hellbent on having their own way, right from the start. They have shown themselves to be corrupt and immoral and I sincerely hope this never goes away. It is a strong belief amongst many that Lennox was in fact killed some time ago, which would explain why they refuse to allowed the family to take the body.

  15. You certaiinly know what you’re talking about! Shame the BCC took advise from so called experts who know nothing about dogs behavior!! God bless Lennox, at least you are no longer scared or in pain, this should never had happened xxxxxx

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s